When selecting a vinyl pool liner, one of the most critical decisions you’ll face is the thickness of the liner. The two most common options homeowners consider are 20 mil and 27 mil vinyl liners. Both offer distinct benefits, but understanding their differences will help you make an informed choice based on the needs of your swimming pool.
Whether you’re planning a new backyard swimming pool design or looking to replace an existing liner, choosing the right thickness is essential to ensure durability, fit, and long-lasting performance.
In this article, we discuss the differences between 20 mil and 27 mil vinyl pool liners, helping you choose the best option for your swimming pool in Toronto.
Vinyl Liner Thickness
What Does “Mil” Mean in Liner Thickness?
In the pool industry, the term “mil” refers to the measurement of thickness, with one mil being equal to one-thousandth of an inch. A 20 mil liner, for example, is 0.020 inches thick, while a 27 mil liner is 0.027 inches thick. While the difference might seem small, this extra 7 mils can significantly impact the liner’s performance and durability.
Differences Between 20 Mil and 27 Mil Liners in Composition
The difference in thickness between a 20 mil and 27 mil liner may be subtle, but it comes down to the composition and the materials used. A 27 mil liner is typically made with a denser, more robust layer of vinyl, often with additional protective coatings that improve its strength and resistance to various elements. On the other hand, 20 mil liners are often more lightweight and may not include as many reinforcing layers. However, both liners are designed to be flexible and durable, making them suitable for different pool designs and budgets.
Durability & Longevity
How Each Thickness Handles Wear and Tear
When it comes to wear and tear, a 27 mil vinyl pool liner tends to outlast a 20 mil liner. The added thickness means it can better withstand the friction caused by pool equipment, foot traffic, and even pets that may use the pool. Over time, a 20 mil liner may show signs of fading, discoloration, or minor damage, especially if exposed to harsh UV rays or chemicals. In contrast, a 27 mil liner offers superior protection against these factors, ensuring a more prolonged lifespan.
Resistance to Punctures, Tears, and Chemical Exposure
One of the key advantages of a 27 mil liner is its enhanced resistance to punctures, tears, and chemical exposure. Since it is thicker, it offers a stronger barrier against sharp objects that might accidentally fall into the pool, such as garden tools or debris. It is also more resistant to the chemicals used in pools, such as chlorine or saltwater, which can cause the liner to degrade over time. A 20 mil liner, while still resilient, might require more frequent maintenance and inspections to ensure it remains intact and fully functional.
Lifespan Expectations for 20 Mil Vs. 27 Mil
The lifespan of a vinyl pool liner depends on various factors, including the liner’s thickness. Typically, a 20 mil liner can last between 7 to 12 years, while a 27 mil liner often lasts 12 to 15 years or longer with proper care. The thicker 27 mil liner is generally a better investment if you plan to stay in your home for many years, as it requires fewer replacements and less frequent maintenance.
Flexibility & Fit
How Thickness Affects Liner Stretch and Installation
The thicker the liner, the less flexible it is. A 20 mil liner is more pliable, making it easier to install and fit into the pool. This can be particularly beneficial for DIY projects or pool shapes that aren’t overly complex. On the other hand, a 27 mil liner may require a bit more effort to install due to its increased rigidity. However, professionals will find it easier to handle during the installation process, as the added thickness ensures a snug fit and less chance of wrinkling or shifting over time.
The Impact of Fit on Pool Shape and Surface Coverage
The thickness of the liner also plays a significant role in how well it conforms to the shape of your pool. Pools with more intricate or irregular shapes, such as those with curves or built-in features, will benefit from a thicker 27 mil liner, as it holds its shape better and provides a more precise fit. While a 20 mil liner may stretch more, it can sometimes have difficulty maintaining a tight fit over complex pool designs, which could result in wrinkles or stretching over time.
Ideal Liner Thickness for Complex Pool Designs
If you have a pool with intricate or custom features, the 27 mil liner is typically the better option. Its added thickness provides extra stability, ensuring that the vinyl pool liner fits well over all of the curves and contours of your pool. For simpler, more straightforward pool designs, a 20 mil liner can still provide excellent coverage without the additional cost of a thicker liner.
Call Us Now for a Free Detailed Quote!
Cost Considerations
Price Differences Between 20 Mil and 27 Mil Liners
One of the first things homeowners consider when selecting a vinyl pool liner is cost. Typically, 27 mil liners are more expensive than 20 mil liners due to their thicker composition and added durability. The price difference can vary based on the brand, design, and pool size, but generally, you can expect to pay 20-30% more for a 27 mil liner compared to a 20 mil option.
While the upfront cost is higher for the thicker liner, the overall investment might be more cost-effective in the long run, depending on your pool usage and maintenance preferences.
Long-Term Value Vs. Initial Investment
While a 20 mil vinyl pool liner may save you money initially, it’s important to consider the long-term value. A thicker 27 mil liner, while more expensive upfront, can last longer, resist wear and tear better, and require fewer repairs or replacements. This makes it a more cost-effective option over time, especially for homeowners who plan to stay in their homes for many years or use their pools frequently.
If you’re looking for a more affordable short-term option and are okay with replacing the liner sooner, a 20 mil liner may fit your budget better.
When Spending More Makes Sense
Spending more on a 27 mil vinyl pool liner makes sense in situations where durability, performance, and long-term value are important. If you live in an area with harsh winters, like Toronto, or if your pool is subjected to heavy usage, the added protection of a 27 mil liner can provide peace of mind that your pool will remain in good condition for years. Additionally, for larger pools or complex backyard swimming pool designs, the thicker liner ensures a better fit and fewer maintenance issues.
However, if you have a smaller pool, rarely use it, or are on a tighter budget, a 20 mil liner may suffice. It’s also a great option for homeowners who plan to sell their homes soon and don’t want to invest too much in pool maintenance.
Maintenance & Repair Factors
Ease Of Cleaning and Maintaining Each Thickness
Both 20 mil and 27 mil vinyl pool liners are relatively easy to clean and maintain. However, the thicker 27 mil liner generally holds up better against stains, fading, and the accumulation of dirt and debris over time. Its extra strength makes it less susceptible to damage from scrubbing or cleaning tools. On the other hand, a 20 mil liner may show signs of wear more quickly, especially if it’s regularly exposed to harsh cleaning methods or chemicals.
In terms of maintenance, both types of liners benefit from regular brushing and the use of a pool vacuum to remove debris. Keeping the water chemistry balanced also ensures that the liner stays in optimal condition, regardless of thickness.
Repairability: Which Liner Is Easier To Patch?
When it comes to repairs, 20 mil vinyl pool liners are generally easier to patch due to their thinner, more flexible nature. However, while easier to repair, they are also more likely to tear or puncture, requiring more frequent attention. In contrast, a 27 mil liner, though harder to patch due to its added thickness, is less likely to suffer damage in the first place, which reduces the need for repairs.
Effects Of Sun Exposure, Chlorine, and Water Chemistry
Sun exposure, chlorine, and water chemistry all have an impact on the longevity of vinyl pool liners. The UV rays from the sun can cause the liner to fade over time, while chemicals like chlorine can degrade the material. A 27 mil liner offers better protection against both of these elements, retaining its colour and structural integrity longer. A 20 mil liner, being thinner, is more vulnerable to UV damage and chemical exposure, potentially requiring more frequent maintenance and liner replacement.
Best Applications for Each Liner Thickness
Ideal Scenarios For Choosing 20 Mil Liners
20 mil vinyl pool liners are a great option for smaller, less frequently used pools. If your backyard swimming pool design is straightforward and doesn’t involve many complex features, a 20 mil liner provides an affordable solution with adequate durability. Additionally, if you live in a region with a mild climate and don’t experience extreme weather conditions, a 20 mil liner may meet your needs without the higher upfront cost of a 27 mil liner.
Situations Where 27 Mil Is the Better Choice
For larger pools, complex pool shapes, or areas with harsh weather conditions (like Toronto’s cold winters and intense summers), a 27 mil liner is a better investment. The thicker liner provides added durability against wear and tear, weather fluctuations, and frequent pool usage. It’s also ideal for homeowners who want a long-term solution with minimal repairs and replacements, ensuring the liner stays in good condition throughout the years.
Pool Types, Climates, and User Needs
If you have a saltwater pool or a pool that uses high levels of chlorine, a 27 mil liner is the better option. The thicker material can handle the chemical exposure better, reducing the likelihood of degradation. Similarly, if your pool is used regularly or by many people, the 27 mil liner will withstand the increased wear and tear, giving you a longer-lasting and more durable surface. For swimming pools in Toronto, where fluctuating weather can put extra stress on the pool, the 27 mil liner’s resilience makes it a smart choice.
Myths & Misconceptions
“Thicker Is Always Better” – Is It True?
While a thicker vinyl liner offers additional durability, it’s not always the best choice for every pool. For example, a smaller, less-used pool might benefit more from a 20 mil liner. It’s essential to consider your pool’s size, usage, and local climate before deciding on the thickness.
Do 27 Mil Liners Last Significantly Longer?
While 27 mil liners generally last longer than 20 mil liners, the difference in longevity depends on the pool’s usage and maintenance. In many cases, the 27 mil liner’s added thickness leads to a more durable and long-lasting product, but proper care and balanced water chemistry can also extend the lifespan of a 20 mil liner.
Addressing Common Pool Owner Concerns
Some pool owners worry that a 27 mil liner might be too rigid or difficult to install. While the thicker material does require more care during installation, it’s well worth the effort for pools with complex designs or harsh conditions. As for cost, the additional investment often pays off in terms of reduced maintenance and longer-lasting performance.
Final Verdict
Industry professionals recommend choosing vinyl pool liners based on your pool’s usage and environment. For homeowners with basic backyard swimming pool designs or pools with light usage, a 20 mil liner is a cost-effective option. However, for those with larger pools, intricate designs, or swimming pools in Toronto exposed to harsh weather, a 27 mil liner provides superior durability and long-term value. Experts agree that while the initial investment is higher, the 27 mil liner’s resilience against wear, chemicals, and sun exposure makes it the better choice for frequent pool users seeking minimal maintenance and extended longevity.
Ready to Upgrade Your Pool? Choose the Best Vinyl Pool Liner Today!
Don’t settle for less when it comes to your pool’s longevity and performance. Whether you’re designing a new backyard swimming pool or replacing your old liner, selecting the right vinyl pool liner is crucial for long-term satisfaction. At Land-Con Luxury Pools, we offer a wide range of high-quality pool design, build, and renovation services tailored to your needs. Our experts can help you choose between 20 mil and 27 mil options to ensure the best fit for your pool.
Contact us at 416-504-5263 or drop a mail at info@landcon.ca for a consultation and get ready to enjoy a beautiful, durable pool for years to come!
Also Read: Vinyl Liner Pool Options: Patterns, Colours, and Designs to Suit Your Style
